On November 18, 2026 the Competition Bureau said the Federal Court has ordered Old Navy and Gap to hand over records and written information for its investigation into possibly false or misleading marketing claims. Read the list of claims under review and it looks like an ordinary sale-week product page: a crossed-out "regular" price, a countdown, a "Selling Fast" badge, a counter of people viewing the item. The release is careful on one point: "There has been no finding of wrongdoing at this time." Black Friday falls on November 27, nine days later. The rules behind the probe apply to any store selling online to Canadians, a two-person Shopify shop included.
What the Bureau is looking at
The Competition Bureau news release of November 18, 2026 lists five types of claims, all examined under the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act:
- Regular prices. The struck-through figure next to a sale price, and whether the item ever really sold at it.
- Urgency cues. Limited-time offers and countdown clocks.
- Scarcity messages. "Selling Fast" or "Only a Few Left".
- Popularity claims. Numbers of shoppers said to be viewing or buying a product.
- Past prices and discounts. Labels such as "Price Drop" or "Best Deal in 30 days".
None of this is new for the Bureau. It warned businesses on November 25, 2025, after a jump in complaints about inflated regular prices, and in November 2024 it had put out a consumer alert on fake urgency cues. Those were warnings. This time the Federal Court has granted an order.
The "regular price" has to pass one of two tests
The Bureau's page on the ordinary selling price gives two tests. A store needs to meet at least one, and keep the proof.
| Test | What has to be true | Period |
|---|---|---|
| Volume test | More than half of the product's sales happened at that price or higher | A reasonable period, usually within a year before or after the promotion |
| Time test | The product was offered in good faith at that price or higher for a substantial period of time | Usually within a year immediately before or after the promotion |
Small stores tend to fail the volume test without noticing. Take a hoodie that launched in September at $89. Through October it mostly sold at $69. On Black Friday the product page says "$89, now $59". Most units went out below $89, and the $89 price did not hold for long, so that comparison probably fails both tests. The cause is often mundane: the theme's "compare at" field kept the September launch price and nobody went back to it.
The November 2025 warning closes with advice on the paperwork. None of it takes long:
- a log of each promotion with its dates, the discount, the regular price it compares against and the exact wording;
- no savings claims you could not back up, even in ads that show no regular price;
- product page and email writers who have read the guidance;
- a second read of the copy before each campaign.
Timers and stock badges
The Bureau's fake urgency cues page describes the patterns it treats as deceptive: a "deal ends soon" offer that keeps going after the stated end; a timer that runs out or resets while the offer is still there; stock lines like "Only 2 left in stock" or "5 other shoppers are also looking at this product right now" that do not match reality.
That last group deserves the first look on a Shopify or WooCommerce store. Plenty of apps ship these widgets with random numbers switched on out of the box, and the store owner may never have opened the settings.
What happens next depends on whether the conduct falls under the civil or the criminal provisions of the Act, the page says. Its list goes from significant monetary penalties and restitution up to prohibition orders and even imprisonment.
A pre-Black Friday check, in the order we would do it
- Pull 12 months of price and sales history for each product that will carry a "was" price. Run it against the volume test and the time test, then save the file with the promotion plan.
- In the theme, go through the "compare at" prices and delete the ones that fail both tests.
- Set every countdown timer to end the sale price at zero. If the app restarts the clock for each new visitor, switch that mode off.
- Low-stock badges and "people viewing" counters go off, unless the app reads your real inventory and real traffic.
- Check that the price and end date match on the product page, in the Google Shopping feed, in Meta ads and in the promo email. Email has its own rules under Canada's anti-spam law (consent, a clear sender, an unsubscribe link that works), set out on the ISED page on CASL consent.
This is a marketing reading of the Bureau's published guidance. A lawyer should look at any specific promotion you are unsure about; the official texts are on the Competition Bureau website.
Sales that still look good in January. Marketing MIX in Ottawa handles online store promotion and marketing for online stores, with product pages and ad campaigns built on prices you can document.
Send a briefFAQ
What did the Competition Bureau announce on November 18, 2026?
The Federal Court granted the Bureau an order requiring Old Navy and Gap to produce records and written information for its investigation into possibly false or misleading marketing claims. The Bureau says there has been no finding of wrongdoing at this time.
When can a store show a "regular price" next to a sale price?
Only when that price meets the volume test (more than half of sales at that price or higher) or the time test (offered in good faith at that price or higher for a substantial period). Both are usually measured over a year before or after the promotion. The store also has to be able to prove it.
Are countdown timers allowed?
A timer that matches the real end of the sale fits the Bureau's guidance. What the guidance goes after are timers that run out or reset while the offer is still available, and "deal ends soon" claims on offers that keep running.





